Best Chicken Soup

September 28, 2009 · 122 comments

Best Chicken Soup Recipe

I know this is a mighty lofty thing to say about a humble soup I came up with while sick, but sniffles or not, this is the best chicken soup recipe… ever! There, I said it, because if ever there was something to stake my reputation on, this here chicken soup would be it, and that’s not the NyQuil talking.

Beyond its curative abilities, chicken soup isn’t something I normally crave. If I’m lucky to have the time to make it from scratch, the meat often ends up dry and stringy by the time the broth is ready, and while I could find a butcher that will sell me chicken bones separately, I don’t really have the will or the energy to look for chicken carcasses when I feel the plague setting in. I know there’s always the canned variety, but eating that musty, watered-down chicken liquid is a bit like fighting Ebola with Echinacea.

I can’t guarantee that this chicken soup will miraculously cure your cold, but it will soothe your inner foodie, with the kind of lingering umami that will have you smacking your lips long after you’ve slurped the last spoonful of the heavenly clear broth. The chicken, carrots, and avocado add a splash of colour to your dreary day, while the variety of flavours and textures they provide titillate your senses at a time when applesauce feels like all you can stomach.

What do you like to eat when you’re sick?

When your home from work sick, you may lack energy, but I’m going to guess you make up for that in time. That’s why this recipe is so perfect. It takes a bit of time to make, but beyond some minimal chopping and dumping, this chicken soup requires almost no effort; and for that, you’re rewarded with a dreamy clear broth and chicken so moist you’d swear it was cooked separately.

The secret lies in the gentle poaching of the chicken, followed by the removal of the meat and simmering of the bones until the soup is full of flavour. I’ve given this a vaguely Latin American twist, but you could have fun with it and make it more Asian by adding ginger and ginseng, or more European with some fresh thyme and rosemary instead of cilantro.

So if you feel the dreaded flu coming on, get thee to the grocery store and find the best quality organic chicken you can, because getting sick sucks, but getting sick with a bowl of this chicken soup to awaken your taste buds and nourish your belly, will make it suck just a little bit less.

Best Chicken Soup

1 whole 3-4lbs chicken
1 medium onion cut into wedges
3 cloves garlic smashed with flat side of knife
2 stalks celery leaves and stems chopped
Stems and roots from 1 bunch of cilantro
2 bay laurel leaves (or 1 california bay leaf)
1 Tbs kosher salt

2 carrots, each cut into 2-3 large pieces
1 avocado
cilantro and lime for serving

Put the chicken in a stock pot just big enough to hold it. Scatter the onion, garlic, celery, cilantro, bay leaves and salt around the chicken. Cover the chicken with water, put a lid on the pot, and bring it to a boil over high heat. Continue boiling for 5 minutes. Then, turn off the heat, allowing the chicken to poach in the water for 45 minutes (don’t open the lid during this time).

When the chicken is cooked, remove it from the stock and allow it to cool off enough to touch. Remove and discard the skin, then strip the meat off the bones into bite size pieces. Cover the chicken and refrigerate until the soup is done.

Return the bones back into the stock pot along with any collected juices from the chicken. Cover, and return the soup to a boil. When it boils, turn down the heat and simmer for 3 hours.

Strain the stock through a fine mesh sieve and discard the solids. Skim off any excess oil then add the soup back to the pot along with the carrots. Cook the carrots until tender and salt the soup to taste.

To serve, put down some chicken, carrots and avocado in a bowl. Pour the hot stock over everything and garnish with cilantro and a wedge of lime.

  • Sarahbrosnan

    Just made this…. Was lovely!

  • Pingback: The Kidney Chronicles, Chapter 1 | teamjk+adventures

  • http://www.facebook.com/jatin.kumar.311 Jatin Kumar

    nice recipes…..<3

  • Pingback: Forget about Chicken Soup for the soul | Scribbles and Tunes

  • Ginger

    Thanks!

  • http://www.facebook.com/mrichmann Mary Clark Richmann

    We made this soup for my daughter who just had minor surgery. She said it was delicious! We actually left the onions and celery in the broth along with the carrots and added some noodles, too.

  • Jason Sayles

    I made this today. It was delicious. I used pearl onions, stewed tomatoes, white beans, and kale instead of celery. This was my first venture into homemade soup, and I’m impressed with the results. I have a friend undergoing chemo, starting next week and I’m going to make this again for him. Thanks for the inspiration!

  • Trecia

    Looks great, smells great…am fixing it now. However, my chicken wasn’t done after 5 minutes of boiling and 45 minutes of poaching. I’ve put it back in the pot to cook more….thinking I will let it boil longer next time. Maybe 10 minutes or so.

    • http://norecipes.com Marc Matsumoto

      Unfortunately there’s a lot of factors that can effect poaching time. How big your chicken is, how cold it was when it went into the pot, how thick your pot is (thicker pots retain heat better), and even how warm your kitchen is. I would not recommend increasing boiling time because it will overcook the breasts, instead you may want to turn the heat back on after about 20 minutes to heat up the water again and then turn it off when it starts to simmer and continue poaching.

  • Teri

    Perfect! The use of cilantro in the broth added a depth of flavor the avocado, cilantro and lime a perfect compliment in flavor and texture.

  • LJ

    Great…Great…Great recipe. I made this for my parents and they absolutely loved it. Thank you.

  • Hillary Casper

    I have been craving chicken soup, but have never made it myself. I searched online and found this recipe. I have also never cooked a whole chicken before! This recipe was awesome! I am most excited by the avocado in the soup, something I’ve never seen before. It adds a really nice creamy texture. I also didn’t fully strain the soup, since I like it more chock full of stuff. I added mushrooms and kale, along w/more celery at the end. I did have to deviate a bit from the recipe because I ran out of time after simmering for 3 hours, and refrigerated the stock and separate chicken overnight, to resume the final cooking step in the morning. I wonder if this was a mistake, because the chicken which seemed so tender when I pulled it apart, was actually tough in the soup. I will definitely make this again! Thank you!

    • http://norecipes.com Marc Matsumoto

      Glad to hear you enjoyed it! It’s best to store the chicken separate from the soup. When you reheat the soup, just place the cooked chicken in the bowls and pour the hot soup over the chicken. The heat from the soup will gently warm up the chicken without overlooking it. If you like your soup very hot, you can boil a kettle of water and use the hot water to heat the bowls before you add the chicken and soup.

  • BrooklynGerry

    Hi Marc
    I made this recipe today ( Tuesday, March 19th) as a preparatory chicken soup for the Passover holiday and I am conducting my 1st Seder in my new apartment in Brooklyn. I didn’t have a whole chicken to use, so I substituted 4 very hefty chicken
    thighs instead. I also added a few more onions, some more carrots and some more celery to your recipe, however, I kept the rest of your recipe pretty much as you had
    written it in your blog. I am looking forward to hearing how my guests like this recipe as I’ve made chicken soup in the past and always get compliments. The recipe sounds wonderful and I am looking forward to making it again.

Previous post:

Next post: