Best Chicken Soup

September 28, 2009 · 109 comments

Best Chicken Soup Recipe

I know this is a mighty lofty thing to say about a humble soup I came up with while sick, but sniffles or not, this is the best chicken soup recipe… ever! There, I said it, because if ever there was something to stake my reputation on, this here chicken soup would be it, and that’s not the NyQuil talking.

Beyond its curative abilities, chicken soup isn’t something I normally crave. If I’m lucky to have the time to make it from scratch, the meat often ends up dry and stringy by the time the broth is ready, and while I could find a butcher that will sell me chicken bones separately, I don’t really have the will or the energy to look for chicken carcasses when I feel the plague setting in. I know there’s always the canned variety, but eating that musty, watered-down chicken liquid is a bit like fighting Ebola with Echinacea.

I can’t guarantee that this chicken soup will miraculously cure your cold, but it will soothe your inner foodie, with the kind of lingering umami that will have you smacking your lips long after you’ve slurped the last spoonful of the heavenly clear broth. The chicken, carrots, and avocado add a splash of colour to your dreary day, while the variety of flavours and textures they provide titillate your senses at a time when applesauce feels like all you can stomach.

What do you like to eat when you’re sick?

When your home from work sick, you may lack energy, but I’m going to guess you make up for that in time. That’s why this recipe is so perfect. It takes a bit of time to make, but beyond some minimal chopping and dumping, this chicken soup requires almost no effort; and for that, you’re rewarded with a dreamy clear broth and chicken so moist you’d swear it was cooked separately.

The secret lies in the gentle poaching of the chicken, followed by the removal of the meat and simmering of the bones until the soup is full of flavour. I’ve given this a vaguely Latin American twist, but you could have fun with it and make it more Asian by adding ginger and ginseng, or more European with some fresh thyme and rosemary instead of cilantro.

So if you feel the dreaded flu coming on, get thee to the grocery store and find the best quality organic chicken you can, because getting sick sucks, but getting sick with a bowl of this chicken soup to awaken your taste buds and nourish your belly, will make it suck just a little bit less.

Best Chicken Soup

1 whole 3-4lbs chicken
1 medium onion cut into wedges
3 cloves garlic smashed with flat side of knife
2 stalks celery leaves and stems chopped
Stems and roots from 1 bunch of cilantro
2 bay laurel leaves (or 1 california bay leaf)
1 Tbs kosher salt

2 carrots, each cut into 2-3 large pieces
1 avocado
cilantro and lime for serving

Put the chicken in a stock pot just big enough to hold it. Scatter the onion, garlic, celery, cilantro, bay leaves and salt around the chicken. Cover the chicken with water, put a lid on the pot, and bring it to a boil over high heat. Continue boiling for 5 minutes. Then, turn off the heat, allowing the chicken to poach in the water for 45 minutes (don’t open the lid during this time).

When the chicken is cooked, remove it from the stock and allow it to cool off enough to touch. Remove and discard the skin, then strip the meat off the bones into bite size pieces. Cover the chicken and refrigerate until the soup is done.

Return the bones back into the stock pot along with any collected juices from the chicken. Cover, and return the soup to a boil. When it boils, turn down the heat and simmer for 3 hours.

Strain the stock through a fine mesh sieve and discard the solids. Skim off any excess oil then add the soup back to the pot along with the carrots. Cook the carrots until tender and salt the soup to taste.

To serve, put down some chicken, carrots and avocado in a bowl. Pour the hot stock over everything and garnish with cilantro and a wedge of lime.

Similar Recipes:

  • Sunchoke Ramp and Nettle Soup
    Sunchoke Ramp and Nettle Soup
    Sopa de Ajo con Huevo
    Sopa de Ajo con Huevo
    Sweet Potato Poutine
    Sweet Potato Poutine
    Skate with wine braised Cipollini and fennel
    Skate with wine braised Cipollini and fennel
    Fiery Cinnamon Cranberry Sauce
    Fiery Cinnamon Cranberry Sauce
    Apfel Käsekuchen
    Apfel Käsekuchen
    • http://tiffanybbrown.com/ tiffany

      add some onion and hominy and this would almost be a chicken pozole.

      • Patricia

        Isn’t there already an onion in the recipe? I do agree adding hominy or homemade noodles to it!

    • http://tiffanybbrown.com/ tiffany

      add some onion and hominy and this would almost be a chicken pozole.

      • Patricia

        Isn’t there already an onion in the recipe? I do agree adding hominy or homemade noodles to it!

    • http://kitchensidecar.blogspot.com/ katiek @kitchensidecar

      that’s a pretty lofty assertion – best ever…

      It looks like what my dad drinks after boiling a chicken ( like hainan style rice broth). The clearness of the broth attests to the quality of your stock.

      Have you tried double boiling like they do in china? Those are some of the best soups I have ever tasted.

    • http://kitchensidecar.blogspot.com katiek @kitchensidecar

      that’s a pretty lofty assertion – best ever…

      It looks like what my dad drinks after boiling a chicken ( like hainan style rice broth). The clearness of the broth attests to the quality of your stock.

      Have you tried double boiling like they do in china? Those are some of the best soups I have ever tasted.

    • http://noobcook.com/ noobcook

      ultimate comfort food, the soup looks light & clear yet rich. and the avocado is such a special touch. I can have this everyday, not just when I’m sick ;)

    • http://noobcook.com noobcook

      ultimate comfort food, the soup looks light & clear yet rich. and the avocado is such a special touch. I can have this everyday, not just when I’m sick ;)

    • http://www.phamfatale.com/ Jackie at PhamFatale.com

      As with many staple dishes, attention to detail is the difference between drab and delicious. Your chicken broth looks perfect, clear and I’m sure so flavorful.

    • http://www.phamfatale.com/ Jackie at PhamFatale.com

      As with many staple dishes, attention to detail is the difference between drab and delicious. Your chicken broth looks perfect, clear and I’m sure so flavorful.

    • http://shewhoeats.blogspot.com/ chika

      Hi Marc,

      As a born-and-bred Japanese, my ultimate go-to food when feeling under the weather definitely is rice porridge. That aside, your chicken soup sounds comforting and looks downright beautiful. And I love it how you have avocado in it! I’ve never tried it in a soup except for chilled ones, purreed… but I’m now tempted to try this way and I don’t have to wait until I start feeling sick, I reckon :)

      Hope you are feeling all better now!

    • http://shewhoeats.blogspot.com/ chika

      Hi Marc,

      As a born-and-bred Japanese, my ultimate go-to food when feeling under the weather definitely is rice porridge. That aside, your chicken soup sounds comforting and looks downright beautiful. And I love it how you have avocado in it! I’ve never tried it in a soup except for chilled ones, purreed… but I’m now tempted to try this way and I don’t have to wait until I start feeling sick, I reckon :)

      Hope you are feeling all better now!

    • http://colloquialcooking.com/ Colloquial Cook

      I don’t really care what I eat when I’m sick so long as someone makes it for me :-D
      So sorry to read you’re unwell! Get better soon! I’m ok so far but with all those sputtering students I wouldn’t bet on it.

    • http://colloquialcooking.com Colloquial Cook

      I don’t really care what I eat when I’m sick so long as someone makes it for me :-D
      So sorry to read you’re unwell! Get better soon! I’m ok so far but with all those sputtering students I wouldn’t bet on it.

    • http://www.shesimmers.com/ Leela@SheSimmers

      Ah, so the trick is in removing the meat from the bones before it turns dry and stringy. Thanks for the tips, Marc. Your chicken soup looks perfect!

    • http://www.shesimmers.com Leela@SheSimmers

      Ah, so the trick is in removing the meat from the bones before it turns dry and stringy. Thanks for the tips, Marc. Your chicken soup looks perfect!

    • http://manggy.blogspot.com/ Manggy

      Would you believe, I go for chicken noodle soup and a burger? Ha ha ha. I hope you’re feeling much better Marc- that soup looks like it could do the trick!

    • http://manggy.blogspot.com Manggy

      Would you believe, I go for chicken noodle soup and a burger? Ha ha ha. I hope you’re feeling much better Marc- that soup looks like it could do the trick!

    • Joanna

      Oh gosh, when I am sick a bowl of chicken soup is pretty much all I crave. I’ll have to try this method, love the idea of removing the meat before it turns dry and mushy.

      I grew up with my mom’s (Jewish) chicken soup, which has parsley and lots of dill as the herbs, plus parsnip. It’s the ultimate comfort food for me – especially with matzah balls. Yum!

    • Joanna

      Oh gosh, when I am sick a bowl of chicken soup is pretty much all I crave. I’ll have to try this method, love the idea of removing the meat before it turns dry and mushy.

      I grew up with my mom’s (Jewish) chicken soup, which has parsley and lots of dill as the herbs, plus parsnip. It’s the ultimate comfort food for me – especially with matzah balls. Yum!

    • http://helene-lacuisine.blogspot.com/ Hélène

      Oh my this looks good. My son has been sick for a while, I should prepare this soup for him.

    • http://helene-lacuisine.blogspot.com/ Hélène

      Oh my this looks good. My son has been sick for a while, I should prepare this soup for him.

    • http://duodishes.com/ The Duo Dishes

      Very deconstructed! Even if you’re not sick, this is a good thing to snack on. Drinking a nice veggie broth in the morning can knock out sniffles too.

    • http://duodishes.com The Duo Dishes

      Very deconstructed! Even if you’re not sick, this is a good thing to snack on. Drinking a nice veggie broth in the morning can knock out sniffles too.

    • http://www.choebrothers.com/ alecho

      with avocado?! that’s freakin’ cool, man! I gotta try this best chicken soup! here I come to cook!!!!

    • http://www.choebrothers.com alecho

      with avocado?! that’s freakin’ cool, man! I gotta try this best chicken soup! here I come to cook!!!!

    • http://staceysnacksonline.com/ Stacey Snacks

      I am sick with a miserable cold…..probably caught on an airplane.
      I made white bean soup with pan fried salami, but your Jewish penicillin sure looks better to me!

      I love chicken soup when I am sick, especially made by my grandmother!

      Feel better.

    • http://staceysnacksonline.com Stacey Snacks

      I am sick with a miserable cold…..probably caught on an airplane.
      I made white bean soup with pan fried salami, but your Jewish penicillin sure looks better to me!

      I love chicken soup when I am sick, especially made by my grandmother!

      Feel better.

    • http://www.whiskblog.com/ Shari

      I love the addition of avocado and cilantro! Hope you feel better!

    • http://www.whiskblog.com/ Shari

      I love the addition of avocado and cilantro! Hope you feel better!

    • http://foodhappens.blogspot.com/ lo

      Just made some chicken stock myself the other day — with an Asian flair. But, this looks awesome. Avocado makes everything better, right? :)

      How’s the cold?

    • http://foodhappens.blogspot.com lo

      Just made some chicken stock myself the other day — with an Asian flair. But, this looks awesome. Avocado makes everything better, right? :)

      How’s the cold?

    • http://baconandrhubarb.blogspot.com/ Rachel (S[d]OC)

      It seems I”m not the only food blogger suffering from a cold. I’m enjoying seeing a few chicken soup recipes to help me get through this creeping crud. It’s as if I’m getting inspriation from the gods by reading food blogs on a sick day. I never thought to use avocados in chicken soup.

      Every time I roast a whole chicken I save the carcasses in the freezer. I also freeze old leftover veggies. That way when I have some free time, I can boil it all down for stock. I make quite a bit of it and freeze whatever I don’t use immediately. I consider it very thrifty of me.

    • http://baconandrhubarb.blogspot.com Rachel (S[d]OC)

      It seems I”m not the only food blogger suffering from a cold. I’m enjoying seeing a few chicken soup recipes to help me get through this creeping crud. It’s as if I’m getting inspriation from the gods by reading food blogs on a sick day. I never thought to use avocados in chicken soup.

      Every time I roast a whole chicken I save the carcasses in the freezer. I also freeze old leftover veggies. That way when I have some free time, I can boil it all down for stock. I make quite a bit of it and freeze whatever I don’t use immediately. I consider it very thrifty of me.

    • http://cheffresco.com/ Cheffresco

      I am so sick right now too! no fun. I totally need this soup!

    • http://cheffresco.com Cheffresco

      I am so sick right now too! no fun. I totally need this soup!

    • http://blog.inomthings.com/ ila

      avocado in chicken soup!? that’s friggin GENIOUS!

    • http://blog.inomthings.com ila

      avocado in chicken soup!? that’s friggin GENIOUS!

    • http://www.whatdoiwant2cooktoday.blogspot.com/ Jan

      Lovely looking soup! Great pictures too as always.

    • http://www.whatdoiwant2cooktoday.blogspot.com Jan

      Lovely looking soup! Great pictures too as always.

    • http://www.chocolateshavings.ca/ chocolate shavings

      That dish almost makes me want to be sick!

    • http://www.chocolateshavings.ca chocolate shavings

      That dish almost makes me want to be sick!

    • http://www.whatmegansmaking.blogspot.com/ megan

      what a good idea. for some reason i never thought to poach the chicken, then simmer the bones! i always just simmer the whole thing for a couple hours. i’ll try this next time i make soup – thanks.

    • http://www.whatmegansmaking.blogspot.com megan

      what a good idea. for some reason i never thought to poach the chicken, then simmer the bones! i always just simmer the whole thing for a couple hours. i’ll try this next time i make soup – thanks.

    • http://www.umamimart.com/ Ryohei

      Marc, what happened to the recipe Daisy mentioned at JS program? I know it’s not visually appealing, but I want someone to go through that process, and I bet you are the one who can justify.

    • http://www.umamimart.com Ryohei

      Marc, what happened to the recipe Daisy mentioned at JS program? I know it’s not visually appealing, but I want someone to go through that process, and I bet you are the one who can justify.

    • http://onlinepastrychef.wordpress.com/ Jenni

      The broth alone is beautiful, but it’s the veg garnishes that make it stunning.

      I make my chicken soup the same way, generally starting w/a whole chicken cut up. Poaching in my previous batch of chicken stock, cutting the meat off the bone and then throwing the bones back in to simmer forever in the double-ish strength stock. Makes a soup so full of gelatin that it sets up like an aspic in the fridge. And I have to credit you with adding a shot of fish sauce these days–that punch of umami puts it in a whole new category of tasty!

    • http://onlinepastrychef.wordpress.com/ Jenni

      The broth alone is beautiful, but it’s the veg garnishes that make it stunning.

      I make my chicken soup the same way, generally starting w/a whole chicken cut up. Poaching in my previous batch of chicken stock, cutting the meat off the bone and then throwing the bones back in to simmer forever in the double-ish strength stock. Makes a soup so full of gelatin that it sets up like an aspic in the fridge. And I have to credit you with adding a shot of fish sauce these days–that punch of umami puts it in a whole new category of tasty!

    • http://onlinepastrychef.wordpress.com/ Jenni

      PS I hope you’re feeling better, Marc:)

    • http://onlinepastrychef.wordpress.com/ Jenni

      PS I hope you’re feeling better, Marc:)

    • http://www.sugarbar.org/ diva

      avocado in chicken soup? interesting! but bet it was a massive pickup for u. hope u’re feeling much better now. x

    • http://www.sugarbar.org diva

      avocado in chicken soup? interesting! but bet it was a massive pickup for u. hope u’re feeling much better now. x

    Previous post:

    Next post: