Bon Appétit Holiday Bake-Off

December 15, 2009 · 68 comments

Bon Appetit Holiday Bake-Off

Click here to read part 1 of this post

Showing up at the Conde-Nast headquarters in Times Square, I was immediately struck by the array of food bloggers gathered together in Bon Appetit’s test kitchen. There were familiar faces like @sassyradish, @jenniferperillo, and @homesicktexan and some less familiar faces like @thehungrymouse from Boston, and @SavorySweetLife, who flew in all the way from Seattle for the event. Even more striking though were the desserts that were being carefully plated all around the kitchen.

Bon Appetit Contestants

Since I was already a little late, I staked out a spot by one of the stoves and grabbed a platter. Despite my lack of planning on the cake itself, I did have one trick up my sleeve. I got my sweet mom to FedEx some of the last remaining persimmon leaves off the tree in our backyard in Napa. The vermillion leaves really helped the cake pop off the white plates and I’m sure they helped my presentation score.

Bon Appetit Bake-Off Judges

Soon, most of the contestants were in the main room mingling, but I was still fussing over my cake and how it was going to get presented. The staff must have been annoyed by how I anal I was being. Still, the surprisingly good wine, and even better company soon lured me out of the kitchen and the judging got underway.

Bon Appetit Bake-Off

With all the stunning desserts lined up, I realized I’d forgotten to eat all day and suddenly had a rumbling in my stomach like the way it gets during late-night blog surfing. Thankfully, the leftovers were slowly moving over to a communal counter, where we got to taste every one of the desserts for ourselves.

Bon Appetit Holiday Bake-Off

My entry, a cream cake with layers of genoise and kabocha mousse went second to last. After introducing it, I quickly mingled my way to the back of the room, afraid to see how the judges would react. I also wanted to grab a piece of my own cake as I hadn’t had a chance to taste my new concoction.

Kabocha Cream Cake

As it turns out, kabocha, the ugly duckling of pumpkins makes a good addition to cake. My experimental, last minute cake squeezed ahead to win a trip to Vegas to attend Bon Appétit’s Vegas Uncork’d. Yep, I’m going to Vegas, Baby!

The Festivus Pear Cake by Mary Ann Porch of Puff & Choux came in a close second and the Holiday Pot Pies by Brownie of Blondie & Brownie (which was one of my personal favourites) came in third.

Everyone’s entries were memorable is some way or other, and I’m really looking forward to making some of the desserts myself, just so I can have one more bite. Check out this slide show to see all the entries.

  • http://www.figandcherry.com/ Christie @ Fig&Cherry

    Congrats Marc! Isn’t it great how Mum’s come in handy no matter what your age? :)

  • http://www.figandcherry.com Christie @ Fig&Cherry

    Congrats Marc! Isn’t it great how Mum’s come in handy no matter what your age? :)

  • http://www.sassyradish.com/ radish

    I’m with Alice, Jennie and Stephane — you more than deserved it! It was so exciting to see you win! And that cake was insane. I had 2 huge pieces – ha. Have a great time in Vegas!!

  • http://www.sassyradish.com radish

    I’m with Alice, Jennie and Stephane — you more than deserved it! It was so exciting to see you win! And that cake was insane. I had 2 huge pieces – ha. Have a great time in Vegas!!

  • http://www.foodgal.com/ Carolyn Jung

    Awesome! You rock! Have a great time in Vegas. Your luck is so good already, you’ll have to try your hand at the casinos, too. I predict a big jackpot. Congrats again. You so deserve it!

  • http://www.foodgal.com Carolyn Jung

    Awesome! You rock! Have a great time in Vegas. Your luck is so good already, you’ll have to try your hand at the casinos, too. I predict a big jackpot. Congrats again. You so deserve it!

  • http://www.tasteslikehome.org/ Cynthia

    CONGRATULATIONS!!!

  • http://www.tasteslikehome.org Cynthia

    CONGRATULATIONS!!!

  • http://staceysnacksonline.com/ Stacey Snacks

    And he is a baker too!

    Wow Marc, that’s great.
    Hope all is well and Happy New Year to you and Liz.

    Best, Stacey

  • http://staceysnacksonline.com Stacey Snacks

    And he is a baker too!

    Wow Marc, that’s great.
    Hope all is well and Happy New Year to you and Liz.

    Best, Stacey

  • http://www.soyoufound.me/ joni

    Congrats! Must be very yummy. :)

  • http://www.soyoufound.me joni

    Congrats! Must be very yummy. :)

  • http://melangerbaking.com/ Julia @ Mélanger

    Well done. I love all your dishes so well deserved! :)

  • http://melangerbaking.com/ Julia @ Mélanger

    Well done. I love all your dishes so well deserved! :)

  • Pingback: No Recipes vol. 17

  • Pingback: Interview with Barbara Fairchild

  • Pingback: Kabocha Cream Cake Recipe

  • Pingback: Show Me Your Rice

Previous post:

Next post: