Foodbuzz 24, 24, 24: No Menus: an underground restaurant affair

September 21, 2008 · 88 comments

The past few weeks have been busy for me, for those that subscribe to my Twitter feed you’ve heard me dropping hints about a secret event that I was hosting. Well, today I get to tell you all about it!

[ No Recipes ] was one of 24 blogs selected to commemorate the official launch of the Foodbuzz Publisher Community by creating a unique meal, then blogging about it. Foodbuzz is a community of food lovers buzzing about everything from restaurants, to food porn, to recipes. While I’m not going to be quitting my day job anytime soon, their Publisher Community helps me pay for some of the costs involved in running this blog through the ads in the right column. If you’re interested in signing your blog up for this program, click here.

From the moment I first got their email calling for proposals I knew exactly what I wanted to do. With the density of over-hyped, over-decorated, over-priced restaurants here in Manhattan, there’s been a food-counter-culture backlash of “underground restaurants” popping up all over town. The term refers to an unlicensed restaurants that opens up for one night, usually out of someone’s apartment. The decor is typically pretty sparse and they are illegal in the way speakeasy’s were during prohibition.

Perhaps the prospect of getting an amazing multi-course dinner for the price of a take-out Chinese meal is the draw, or maybe it’s the surreptitious nature of the dining experience. Whatever the case, underground restaurants have been growing in popularity in big cities around the world.

I set out to turn my 550 sq/ft hole-in-the-wall apartment into a comfortable dining experience rivaling someone of my favourite Manhattan restaurants. Being one that likes a challenge (and one that likes to support sustainable agriculture), I also committed to sourcing the majority of my ingredients locally.

While it wasn’t simple, turning my living room and kitchen into a restaurant proved a lot easier than sourcing all my food locally. In the end I’d say I got about 80% of my ingredients from producers within a couple hundred miles of NYC.

I started with small vendors specializing in local goods like Saxelby Cheesemonger in Essex Market and Vintage New York in SoHo. Then there were many trips to the local Green Markets held throughout the week in the parks around New York City. As a last resort I found that Wholefoods actually has a decent selection of locally sourced food, all of which is conveniently labeled with a big green “local” sticker.

By buying local goods you not only help out small family run farms, but you’re also reducing your carbon footprint because it doesn’t need to be trucked/trained/flown in from across the country.

The social and environmental impact aside, I like buying local because the food just tastes better and is better for you. With fruit they are typically organic and riper/sweeter because they don’t have to be picked green (to survive the shipping time). Meat tends to be more flavorful because the animals are fed wholesome natural diets rather than the hormone and antibiotic laden formulas used in overcrowded feedlots trying to maximize a large corporation’s bottom line.




For those that have wondered what you can accomplish in the trailer-home-sized kitchens provided with most Manhattan apartments, this whole dinner (as well as every recipe on this blog) was prepped in this kitchen. No, there isn’t more to it that’s been cropped off, that’s all of it. This shot was taken from the middle of my living room.

After a day of work, the theft of 2 folding chairs from work, and the acquisition of a $20 card table off Craigslist, I was in business. I set up a dimmer on the room lighting and used candles on the tables to create some ambiance. The glassware and flatware were a bit of a grab bag, but I figured I could pass that off euphemistically as “charm”.

So what was for dinner at No Menus? Read on for the course-by-course replay. Hit the links for recipes.

Faux Gras de Poulet with vanilla white plum preserve and brioche

Frozen Caprese Salad – Heirloom tomato granita on top of basil and fresh mozzarella

Kuromitsu pork chop served with kinako powder and creamy maple polenta succotash

Selection of four local cheeses: Mecox Sunrise, Prima Cacciotta, Sprout Creek Rita, Old Chatham Ewe’s Blue


Kaffir Lime yogurt panna cotta with a summer rasberry puree

The best part? This restaurant comes with a couch to lounge around on after dinner.

For more photos of the event check out our Flickr album. Many thanks go out to Foodbuzz for making this happen, as well as all the local vendors for putting up with my incessant questions about the source of their food. Also special thanks to L for all her help in making this thing happen.

Disclaimer: For any city health inspectors that may be reading this post, I didn’t collect any money from my guests, so there was no food being sold to the public.

  • http://palachinka.blogspot.com/ Marija

    WOW! I wish I could have been there! Great post and the photos are fantastic!

  • http://palachinka.blogspot.com/ Marija

    WOW! I wish I could have been there! Great post and the photos are fantastic!

  • http://evanhaveman.com/ Evan

    Dude! Looks amazing… I’ll give you plenty of notice for my next NYC trip so you can start planning a sequel!

  • http://evanhaveman.com Evan

    Dude! Looks amazing… I’ll give you plenty of notice for my next NYC trip so you can start planning a sequel!

  • http://www.cannelle-vanille.blogspot.com/ Aran

    that sounds like so much fun! great job!

  • http://www.cannelle-vanille.blogspot.com Aran

    that sounds like so much fun! great job!

  • Holly and Kelly

    Thanks for a great experience and a great meal! We are still dreaming about the panna cotta…

  • Holly and Kelly

    Thanks for a great experience and a great meal! We are still dreaming about the panna cotta…

  • http://www.cookeatfret.com/ claudia (cook eat FRET)

    really impressive. you did an absolutely beautiful job. i hope you feel pretty damn good about yourself!

  • http://www.cookeatfret.com claudia (cook eat FRET)

    really impressive. you did an absolutely beautiful job. i hope you feel pretty damn good about yourself!

  • http://www.foodnewsandreviews.blogspot.com/ Laurie

    These cheese selection and the lime yogurt panna cotta look wonderful! Wow.. creamy maple polenta, how interesting! I love your collage and use of white.. yes, it did the trick to enlarge your space! Congrats and wonderful write up! :)

  • http://www.foodnewsandreviews.blogspot.com Laurie

    These cheese selection and the lime yogurt panna cotta look wonderful! Wow.. creamy maple polenta, how interesting! I love your collage and use of white.. yes, it did the trick to enlarge your space! Congrats and wonderful write up! :)

  • http://www.thursdaynightsmackdown.com/ michelle @ TNS

    that pork chop was OFF THE FUCKING HOOK. and i still don’t know how he cooked in the 7 square feet of kitchen he had to work with, i think he’s some kind of wizard, or possible a wizard.

    thanks so much for inviting us – we had a great time!

  • http://www.thursdaynightsmackdown.com michelle @ TNS

    that pork chop was OFF THE FUCKING HOOK. and i still don’t know how he cooked in the 7 square feet of kitchen he had to work with, i think he’s some kind of wizard, or possible a wizard.

    thanks so much for inviting us – we had a great time!

  • http://www.hungryandfrozen.blogspot.com/ Laura @ Hungry and Frozen

    Marc, what an amazing idea! The meal looks incredible…like something out of a restaurant, not someone’s apartment :) Well done!

    By the way, I think my kitchen is actually smaller than yours…and five people share it LOL. Looking forward to reading all the recipes.

  • http://www.hungryandfrozen.blogspot.com Laura @ Hungry and Frozen

    Marc, what an amazing idea! The meal looks incredible…like something out of a restaurant, not someone’s apartment :) Well done!

    By the way, I think my kitchen is actually smaller than yours…and five people share it LOL. Looking forward to reading all the recipes.

  • http://manggy.blogspot.com/ Manggy

    That is one delicious menu! It’s also great that you used local produce– amazing how much more care one guy in his apartment can show than hundreds of restaurants in the area that actually function with licenses and stuff! Good job!

  • http://manggy.blogspot.com Manggy

    That is one delicious menu! It’s also great that you used local produce– amazing how much more care one guy in his apartment can show than hundreds of restaurants in the area that actually function with licenses and stuff! Good job!

  • http://www.figandcherry.com/ Christie@fig&cherry

    Well done Marc – you pulled it off beautifully! I find it funny that we both did a deconstructed take on Caprese salad – food blogger psychic abilities? I think so.

    Also, I’m jealous of your fridge so big and shiny!!

  • http://www.figandcherry.com/ Christie@fig&cherry

    Well done Marc – you pulled it off beautifully! I find it funny that we both did a deconstructed take on Caprese salad – food blogger psychic abilities? I think so.

    Also, I’m jealous of your fridge so big and shiny!!

  • http://www.cakespy.com/ Cakespy

    I love the concept–and how awesome that afterward, there’s a nice sofa to lounge on and reflect / digest!! The cheeses…the pork chop…the salad…oh, everything!

  • http://www.redcook.net Kian

    What a wonderful menu! Let me know when you really start operating an underground restaurant.

  • http://www.cakespy.com Cakespy

    I love the concept–and how awesome that afterward, there’s a nice sofa to lounge on and reflect / digest!! The cheeses…the pork chop…the salad…oh, everything!

  • http://www.redcook.net Kian

    What a wonderful menu! Let me know when you really start operating an underground restaurant.

  • http://feedingmaybelle.blogspot.com/ maybelles mom (feeding maybell

    thanks for visiting my post. Yours looks delicious–I particularly love the caprese salad idea. I would definitely have attended (and might have even paid.)

  • http://feedingmaybelle.blogspot.com maybelles mom (feeding maybelle)

    thanks for visiting my post. Yours looks delicious–I particularly love the caprese salad idea. I would definitely have attended (and might have even paid.)

  • http://www.zenkimchi.com/FoodJournal ZenKimchi

    I can barely make a dish for a potluck. Forget about turning my apartment into a restaurant!

  • http://www.zenkimchi.com/FoodJournal ZenKimchi

    I can barely make a dish for a potluck. Forget about turning my apartment into a restaurant!

  • http://www.souvlakiforthesoul.com/ Peter G

    You put on a beautiful spread Marc…absolutely stunning! It was great getting a peek into your apartment as well. Great job!

  • http://www.souvlakiforthesoul.com Peter G

    You put on a beautiful spread Marc…absolutely stunning! It was great getting a peek into your apartment as well. Great job!

  • http://constableslarder.blogspot.com/ Giff

    I was looking forward to reading what you pulled off! Looks fabulous, and I’m going to have to check out the details once I regain some energy from today’s marathon posting (and I can’t stop editing ;-) ).

    Now for some No Recipes Recipes. :)

  • http://constableslarder.blogspot.com/ Giff

    I was looking forward to reading what you pulled off! Looks fabulous, and I’m going to have to check out the details once I regain some energy from today’s marathon posting (and I can’t stop editing ;-) ).

    Now for some No Recipes Recipes. :)

  • http://voodoolily.blogspot.com/ Heather

    What a fantastic idea, Marc, and beautifully executed. Great job!

    Next time, West Coast!

  • http://voodoolily.blogspot.com Heather

    What a fantastic idea, Marc, and beautifully executed. Great job!

    Next time, West Coast!

  • http://jodimop.wordpress.com/ FoodJunkie

    WOW fantastic idea, post and photos. You had a great time, probably as good as we did :-)

  • http://jodimop.wordpress.com FoodJunkie

    WOW fantastic idea, post and photos. You had a great time, probably as good as we did :-)

  • http://aroundbritainwithapaunch.blogspot.com/ Jonathan

    This sounds and looks incredible. I can’t wait for something like this to happen in London.

  • http://aroundbritainwithapaunch.blogspot.com/ Jonathan

    This sounds and looks incredible. I can’t wait for something like this to happen in London.

  • http://tastewiththeeyes.blogspot.com/ Lori Lynn

    Fabulous! What a great idea for the 24 24 24! Your menu is so interesting, everything with a twist. I would have been happy there for sure! Here’s to your successful evening. Congratulations!

  • http://tastewiththeeyes.blogspot.com/ Lori Lynn

    Fabulous! What a great idea for the 24 24 24! Your menu is so interesting, everything with a twist. I would have been happy there for sure! Here’s to your successful evening. Congratulations!

  • http://www.sugarbar.org/ diva

    marc, what a wonderful event to hold! and the table decor is lovely. the menu looks fantastic as well – well I know it’s ‘No Menu’ but the dishes you served are beautiful. and I didn’t know underground restaurants existed! how interesting

  • http://www.sugarbar.org diva

    marc, what a wonderful event to hold! and the table decor is lovely. the menu looks fantastic as well – well I know it’s ‘No Menu’ but the dishes you served are beautiful. and I didn’t know underground restaurants existed! how interesting

  • http://kalofagas.blogspot.com/ Peter

    Fabulous dinner, sometimes the meal is eaten on the sofa too!

  • http://kalofagas.blogspot.com/ Peter

    Fabulous dinner, sometimes the meal is eaten on the sofa too!

  • http://sassandveracity.typepad.com/ kellypea

    Outstanding idea! A lot of work, but well worth it when I look at that menu. I, too, ask a lot of questions about where our food comes from. So far, they’ve all been patient!

  • http://sassandveracity.typepad.com kellypea

    Outstanding idea! A lot of work, but well worth it when I look at that menu. I, too, ask a lot of questions about where our food comes from. So far, they’ve all been patient!

  • http://foodwoolf.com/ Food Woolf

    An amazing idea and an even more incredible apartment transformation! It’s incredible what you can do in the kitchen when you put your mind to it…I guess it’s time for me to open my own restaurant (in my apartment!)

    thanks for the inspiration!

  • http://foodwoolf.com Food Woolf

    An amazing idea and an even more incredible apartment transformation! It’s incredible what you can do in the kitchen when you put your mind to it…I guess it’s time for me to open my own restaurant (in my apartment!)

    thanks for the inspiration!

  • http://www.weareneverfull.com/ We Are Never Full

    inspiring! we once had 10 people for dinner in our 750 square footer and that was tough. gotta do a dance to get around people.

    this looks creative and delicious. anytime you need guests, we’re only a borough away ;)

  • http://www.weareneverfull.com We Are Never Full

    inspiring! we once had 10 people for dinner in our 750 square footer and that was tough. gotta do a dance to get around people.

    this looks creative and delicious. anytime you need guests, we’re only a borough away ;)

Previous post:

Next post: